Getting Website Traffic but No Sales? Here's What to Check First

What to Send After Someone Downloads Your Lead Magnet

October 22, 2026•11 min read

Someone downloads your freebie, joins your email list and receives the resource they signed up for.

Now what?

For many coaches and course creators, this is where the emails start becoming a collection of tips, updates and occasional promotions.

You send a welcome email, share some helpful advice and eventually introduce your coaching programme or course.

But when you look at the results, people are opening your emails without showing much interest in what you're selling.

The problem isn't necessarily how many emails you're sending. It's what those emails are helping people understand.

Someone downloading your free resource doesn't automatically understand why they need your paid programme.

They signed up for help with a particular problem. They may know very little about your wider work, how you help people or what makes your paid offer relevant to them.

Your follow-up emails need to make that connection.

Here's how to approach it.

1. Start with the reason someone downloaded your freebie

Before writing your welcome sequence, look at what brought people onto your list.

What were they trying to achieve when they signed up?

What did your freebie promise to help them with?

And how does that connect to your paid programme?

Take a career coach who helps experienced professionals change careers.

She offers a free guide about working out whether it's time to leave their current career.

Someone downloads it because they've been unhappy at work for months. They're tired of feeling stuck, but they don't know whether changing careers is realistic.

The coach's paid programme helps people explore new career options, make a practical plan and move towards a different career.

That's a clear connection.

But the person who downloaded the guide hasn't necessarily decided they want to change careers.

They're still trying to work out whether it's the right decision.

Sending an email the next day promoting a £500 career-change course may be too big a step.

Before introducing the programme, the coach needs to help subscribers work through some of the questions they're already facing.

How do they know whether it's the career that's wrong or their current job?

What options do they have?

Can they make a change without putting their financial security at risk?

Those concerns give the coach a much stronger starting point for her emails than a generic welcome sequence.

Check This First

Open your freebie and read the promise on the signup page.

What is someone hoping to achieve when they download it?

What questions are likely to come up as they start using it?

Which of those questions connect to the help you provide inside your paid programme?

These are the subjects your follow-up needs to address.

If you're unsure whether the freebie is bringing in people who need your paid offer, start by checking whether your lead magnet is attracting the right people.

2. Your first email has one important job

The first email needs to deliver what you promised.

If someone signed up for a guide, send them the guide.

Make the link easy to find, explain what they've received and help them get started.

This sounds obvious, but there's an important difference between delivering a resource and helping someone use it.

Take a life coach offering a workbook to help women identify what's keeping them stuck after a major life change.

The welcome email can deliver the workbook and point subscribers towards the first exercise.

It can explain what that exercise helps them work out and encourage them to spend a few minutes completing it.

Now the subscriber has a reason to open the resource rather than save it somewhere and forget about it.

You can introduce yourself briefly, particularly if people have found you through a collaboration, podcast or social media post and aren't familiar with your work.

But there's no need to turn the first email into your entire life story or a long explanation of everything you offer.

Deliver the resource, help people use it and give them a reason to pay attention to what comes next.

Check This First

Look at your current welcome email.

Is the free resource immediately accessible?

Does the email explain how to get started?

Can subscribers understand what they're going to get from using it?

And do they have a clear reason to open your next email?

3. Use the next emails to address what happens after the freebie

This is where a lot of email sequences lose direction.

The subscriber receives the resource, followed by more helpful information about the same general subject.

A nutrition coach sends a meal plan, then more recipes.

A business coach sends a planning worksheet, then more productivity tips.

A life coach sends a confidence workbook, then more motivational advice.

There's nothing wrong with continuing to share useful information.

But if every email delivers another standalone tip, people can stay on your list for months without understanding what your paid programme actually helps them achieve.

The follow-up needs to build on what they've already received.

Take the nutrition coach offering a seven-day meal plan. The first email delivers the plan.

The next could address a difficulty people encounter when trying to follow it.

Perhaps the plan works well for the first few days, but their schedule changes and they struggle to stay consistent.

That's a useful subject for an email.

The coach can explain how to adapt a meal plan when life gets busy and why consistency becomes difficult when someone relies entirely on ready-made plans.

Another email could explore the difference between following a plan for a week and building eating habits that work long term.

Now subscribers are learning something that goes beyond the original resource.

And they're beginning to understand the problems that personalised nutrition coaching is designed to help them solve.

The emails still need to be useful on their own.

But each one has a purpose in helping people understand their situation and what they may need next.

Check This First

Read the first few emails someone receives after downloading your freebie.

Are you building on the problem that brought them to you?

Or are you sending more information that doesn't connect to the result your programme helps people achieve?

Look at what your subscribers are likely to struggle with after using the free resource.

That's a good place to find subjects for your next emails.

Your lead magnet gives people a reason to join your list. Your emails need to give them a reason to buy.

4. Show people how your paid programme helps

At some point, your subscribers need to understand what you're selling.

And mentioning your programme occasionally isn't the same as helping someone decide whether it's right for them.

Take our career coach.

Her free guide helped subscribers understand whether they want to change careers.

Her emails have addressed some of the concerns that come with making that decision.

Now she can introduce the programme and explain how it helps people move forward.

What does someone work through inside the course?

How does it help them explore realistic career options?

What support do they receive when they're unsure which direction to take?

What can they expect to have worked out by the end?

These are useful details for someone considering the programme.

But don't make the email a long list of modules, worksheets and bonuses.

People need to understand what those things help them do.

If your programme includes a module about identifying transferable skills, explain how that helps someone recognise career opportunities they hadn't previously considered.

If you provide individual feedback, explain where that support makes a difference.

If previous clients have achieved relevant results, share examples that help subscribers understand what's possible and what the process involves.

The aim is to give people enough information to make an informed decision.

Check This First

Look at the emails where you introduce your paid offer.

Can someone understand who the programme is for?

What problem does it help solve?

How does the support differ from what they've already received for free?

And is the next step clear?

Don't assume that people understand the value of your programme because they've enjoyed your free content.

5. Give people a clear opportunity to buy

Once you've helped subscribers understand the problem and how your course or programme addresses it, make an invitation.

Tell them about the offer.

Explain what they'll receive, who it's designed for and what they need to do next.

If you're selling an online course, that may mean visiting the sales page to see the full details and enrol.

If you're selling coaching, the next step could be reading about your programme or applying to work with you.

Whatever the next step is, make it obvious.

And give people a reason to take it.

An email announcing that your programme exists isn't particularly compelling to someone who hasn't connected it to their own situation.

An email explaining how your programme helps them solve a problem they've been dealing with is more relevant.

You don't need to hide the offer until the end of a long sequence, either.

Some people will already be looking for paid support when they download your freebie.

Make it possible for them to explore your offer earlier.

Others need more time and information.

Your emails can support both without treating every subscriber as though they're at exactly the same point.

Check This First

Open the email where you first introduce your programme.

Is the invitation clear?

Have you explained why someone who downloaded your freebie may be interested in the offer?

Is there an obvious link to the sales page or next step?

Then look at what happens when people click.

If subscribers are visiting your sales page but aren't buying, investigate what happens there before rewriting the entire sequence.

6. Decide what happens when someone doesn't buy

Not everyone who downloads your freebie is ready to invest in your paid course or programme.

Some need time to make a decision.

Others are interested in the subject but don't currently need the support you're selling.

And some are considering your offer but still have questions.

Your email sequence shouldn't end with one invitation followed by months of unrelated newsletters.

Think about what happens next.

Someone who clicked through to your programme may benefit from an email addressing a common concern about joining.

Someone who hasn't shown interest in the paid offer may need more useful information related to the problem that brought them to you.

And someone who is already a customer shouldn't keep receiving the same introductory promotion.

This is where email automation can help, particularly when you're selling a course or coaching programme on an ongoing basis.

You can create different follow-up paths based on what people have done, without making your entire email system unnecessarily complicated.

Start with what you already know about your subscribers and the decisions they need to make.

Check This First

Look at what happens after your first invitation to buy.

Do subscribers hear about your programme again?

Are you addressing common questions that stop people from moving forward?

What happens to people who click but don't purchase?

And are new customers removed from emails promoting something they've already bought?

A good follow-up doesn't need to become endless.

It needs to keep helping people make an informed decision about whether your programme is right for them.

How many emails should you send after someone downloads your freebie?

There's no fixed number that works for every business.

A short freebie connected to a low-cost course may need less explanation than a free training leading into a £1,000 coaching programme.

The amount of follow-up depends on what you're selling, how familiar subscribers already are with your work and what they need to understand before buying.

For many coaches and course creators, four to six focused emails can provide a useful starting point.

That gives you room to deliver the resource, address the problem, build understanding of the paid programme and make a clear invitation.

Then you can continue your regular emails or create additional follow-up based on subscriber interest.

The important thing is having a reason for each email.

Adding more emails won't automatically lead to more sales if the existing messages aren't helping people understand why they'd want your programme.

Before you rewrite your email sequence

If people are downloading your freebie but aren't buying your course or coaching programme, start by looking at the whole process.

Who is joining your list?

What are they expecting when they sign up?

What does your freebie help them achieve?

And what do they need to understand before considering your paid offer?

Then look at your emails.

Do they build on the reason someone joined?

Do they help subscribers understand the value of your paid programme?

Are you making a clear invitation to buy?

And what happens when people aren't ready?

You may discover that you need a better welcome email.

You may need to change the order of your messages or make your paid offer clearer.

Or you may find that your emails are doing their job and the problem is somewhere else.

If you're already getting traffic and subscribers but not enough customers, here's what to check before making changes to your funnel.

Your freebie gives people a reason to join your list. Your follow-up needs to give them a reason to consider your paid programme.

Before adding more emails, make sure the ones you're already sending are doing that job.

Alexandra Stancu

Alexandra Stancu

I help coaches and course creators sell their expertise online and turn more of the people already finding them into customers.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog